Showing posts with label libraries. Show all posts
Showing posts with label libraries. Show all posts

Saturday, January 14, 2012

Stop Bothering Society, Poor Kid: Help Yourself!

People who know me, know that I am a firm believer in systemic inequalities. Our country has done a lot to reduce the legal barriers that inhibited certain races from realizing their full potential (though much still remains). That said, in a country that was built on slavery and did not fully protect the rights of Blacks in law until the Civil Rights Act of 1964, you have to imagine that the way the country operates is still favorable to Whites. Even if you full equalized everyone in law and you enforced those laws properly, all American institutions and measures of success are largely based upon White measures of success. Specifically, the White middle and upper class. This article may make you uncomfortable if you are squeamish about talking about race and class (or dislike sarcasm), but my philosophy is that you cannot fix a problem by ignoring it and political correctness is the quickest path to inertia.

An article recently published in Forbes Magazine, entitled “If I Were a Poor Black Kid” recently caught my attention. I responded to the article and then to the author’s response in forceful (and recognizable) terms My intent here is not to rehash my response, but to outline the problem with this author’s overly simplistic assessment and to go one step further by showing the math that debunks his “solution.”

Hey Black Kids, Follow the Binary Road!

Anytime someone who has never been poor or Black and who is not a kid decides to write a treatise on what poor, Black children should do…you should be apprehensive. In the article, a man who is a middle class (and always was middle class) technology expert gives advice to poor black children on how they themselves can and should lift themselves out of poverty. This advice includes:

  • Getting good grades
  • Using all the free sites on the web like Ted Talks, Cliff’s Notes (a real resource for understanding literature), Google Scholar and Project Gutenberg to do well.
  • Finding study partners and using Skype to hone your intellect
  • Making sure you get into an elite charter school or get a full ride to a private school
  • Sucking up to the guidance counselor so that they help you find jobs, college, and other opportunities
  • Learning software programming or computers or another "skill."


All of this advice builds to the conclusion that “Technology can help these kids. But only if the kids want to be helped. Yes, there is much inequality. But the opportunity is still there in this country for those that are smart enough to go for it.” (so, you see, poor, Black people are not smart because they aren't trying to not be poor...that is what you are saying, right sir?)

Wait, There Are Holes in This Guy’s Logic!?

Technology was good for this author: rather than giving him a healthy dose of my backhand, he only had to face my comments. As someone who grew up poor in a big city and who ended up going to Stanford, I actually have a lot of relevant experience to comment on this article (which he denied because poor kids, even after going to Stanford, are not smarter than he). A big part of his solution involves poor kids using computers, and he suggests that in the “unlikely event” that they don’t have one, they can just go to one of their wonderful public libraries.

The problem with libraries

As a child, I DID that. I went to the library, and I almost never touched a computer because poor kids (of all races) are competing with retired, unemployed, homeless people and others. Many computers also have a time restriction (in Chicago it was 30 minutes if someone is waiting, which they always were). Further, some of the things he mentions (google scholar, TED) can probably be accessed from a library computer. That said, most do not have the software or hardware for using Skype or for learning how to code. Further, if you don’t live near a library or it is in a sketchy area, the journey there could be dangerous.

Finally, I did a little calculation using Philadelphia to demonstrate the absurdity of his proposal:

According to the most recent census data, approximately 36,000 children in Philadelphia would be considered “poor, Black kids.” (I calculated this by multiplying Philly’s population by the percentage under age 18, multiplied by the percentage of people who are black, multiplied by the percentage of people who are “in poverty,” which probably understates the amount of people who might benefit from his “solutions.”) According to the Philadelphia Public Library Website, there are 68 public libraries. Not all libraries are open right now, no libraries appear to be open on Sundays, so I am again overstating the library’s ability to absorb people. Libraries are open from 9am to 8pm generally 5 days a week and 9 am until 5 pm on Saturdays (not all, but I’ll be generous). That means each library is open 3,285 hours a year. With 68 libraries, the whole system is open 223,380 hours a year. Let’s assume that each has an average of 20 computers (unlikely, but what the heck, we are white and middle class!). Then the system has just under 4.5 million computer hours to offer to poor black kids. That means, each of our 36,000 poor, black kids gets 125 hours with a computer per year if most skipped school for their allotment and if all other library patrons were banned from the computers. This also assumes perfect mobility and that all kids in poor neighborhoods have equal access to equally capacious libraries, which is a stretch.

Now, with about 1,200 of those library hours occurring during school time (40, five-day weeks lasting from 9am until 3pm), each library can realistically only offer 2,085 hours per year, reducing the system’s capacity to 142,000 non-school hours per year, and with 20 computers assumed per library about 2.8 million computer hours. This amounts to 78 hours per “poor, black kid.” How many skills have you mastered by dedicating 78 hours per year? Now if you assume that a kid needs about 30 minutes of homework help for the 200 days that school is in session, that leaves the kid with -22 hours for learning how to code. How many skills have you learned in -22 hours?

As I noted in my article on teachers correcting for systemic inequality, Chicago just moved to close most of its libraries on Mondays. With many cities facing budget shortfalls, the likelihood that public libraries can serve our nation’s poor as much as is needed to escape poverty is decreasing by the day.

Non-logistical problems with the article

Now, aside from the absurd idea that every kid can get the computer access they need to be able to use technology to solve all of their problems, there are many more problems with the author’s arguments:

1. Think back to high school…how was your guidance counselor? I lucked the heck out and I had a great one who helped me apply to colleges, but with a parent that had not gone to college and being in one of the worst public school systems in the nation, the likelihood that this is a sure path is very low.

2. When you are in a single-parent home or have no parents or your parents are working so much that they cannot help you with homework, how do you get good grades? How do you find out about all of these tech resources? How do you know to read interesting middle class guys on Forbes.com to save you from your poverty?

3. The Harvard Business Review recently wrote several articles that note that most people fail to achieve their goals because they are contingent upon things outside of themselves (for example, if I set the goal "get more hits on my blog," that is outside of myself, because you choose to come here, I can't force you...better goals might be: write more posts, leave the link to my blog in other fora, and use social media to attract people to my blog, all of which I can control). Getting good grades depends a lot a teacher’s subjective assessment, having enough food to be able to concentrate on studying/homework, having utilities to be able to see or not shiver to do your homework (or to go online if you are one of the many poor black kids with computers!), or having access to homework help.

4. I noted that the system is probably rigged in subtle ways to favor its creators: higher income whites. Kids are actually quite receptive to this, and kids have to have a lot of willpower to overcome the stigma that being studious often comes with. Many poor black kids get teased or bullied if they try to be studious, often for “acting white.” An educated child also experiences a lot of distance with their less educated family, which can make it tough to keep fighting an uphill battle.

5. The article ignores entirely the severe disadvantages with which most poor kids enter the public school system. The lack of preschool or structured afterschool programming sets them up to be disadvantaged going in. Further, given the amount of tracking (assigning kids to a regular or more accelerated class which usually determines their future trajectory), many kids may already be routed into the “slow lane" of public education.

6. If kids need to fight to get into good schools, then you are admitting that the public school system is failing them in a disproportionate way, which is antithetical to the point of PUBLIC education, as I noted in my article on charters. As the propaganda film “Waiting for Superman” clearly shows, there is not enough supply of charter /private school seats for poor pupils.

7. It is really hard to fight for 78 hours of public library time after school while also getting a job or internship care of your amazing guidance counselor. Further, what if you are an older sibling caring for your younger siblings?

8. Did you skip childhood? Do you know how hard and counterintuitive it is for a child to be that self-disciplined? Part of the advantage that all higher-income kids have is that they are embedded in a web of discipline that is geared toward doing well in school.

9. This article is incredibly paternalistic (I won’t go so far as to say that the author is racist, because I think he believes his ignorant, ill-informed ideas and thinks that they really are a way to help poor kids.). One, it assumes knowledge of something that the author has never experienced. Two, it assumes that poor, black people should work themselves into the ground to be qualified to serve people like him and his business needs.

10. The article completely removes all culpability from the system or from wealthier people. It is rather unfair that his kids, which he notes “have it a lot easier” and not inherently smarter than their lower-income counterparts, do not have to bootstrap their way to the top. I can’t help but wonder if the author were writing in 1840 if the article would blame slaves for not working hard to cozy up to their masters, save up, and buy their freedom. Life is unfair, but let’s not pretend like this is good for our country. We need to attract and keep good teachers. We need for kids to have proper nutrition. We need for kids to have more equal opportunities to succeed or take advantage of an extra-curricular program/job (within the bounds of child labor laws, please!). We need excellent guidance counselors and capacious libraries. We need safe streets. We need to enable working parents to better participate in their kid’s education and put food on the table.

If I Were an Ignorant, Middle-Class Dude

This is my challenge to Gene Marks, the author of this article: put your money where your mouth is. You, as a high-tech employer are probably suffering from a dearth of high-quality talent, so you benefit from having more people to choose from. Further, as a father, it should concern you when kids are unable to escape poverty and realize their full potential. As a taxpayer, you subsidize all the kids’ education that gets wasted when they drop out, their higher incidence of crime (prison is costly!), their higher likelihood to have a teenage pregnancy, and their lower wages that may push them onto the dole. You have a vested interest as a businessman, father, and taxpayer to help poor kids succeed.

I therefore challenge you to go to North and West Philly and take a handful of poor children under your wing. Find them consistent, regular access to a computer and help orient them to all the tools out there. Give them internships. Help them to learn a skill. Give them strategies and structure to help them navigate their school, extracurriculars, and college effectively. Then report back to everyone on all the challenges your article didn’t account for. Report on the amount of resources that it took for you to succeed.

Mr. Marks, my issue with your article was not that the solutions themselves are bad. I used several of them to succeed: I worked my ass off to get good grades and get into magnet schools, I befriended my high school counselor, I went to the library most days of the week, and I taught myself one (and then several) foreign languages. My concern is that it is impractical to expect a kid without any guidance to even think to do all these things, especially when they are logistically improbable. So help some kids to think of these solutions and to carry them out. I want more kids to succeed like me, but I know that my success and theirs is tied to the amount of people who are willing to offer extra guidance and to the ability of the school system and libraries to support and reinforce these kids’ successes.

Act on it!

  • Write Mr. Marks or comment on the Forbes article and encourage him to accept my challenge. Write other businessmen and encourage them to offer guidance and cultivate a generation of leaders from the lower-rungs of the socioeconomic ladder of society.
  • Take a kid under your wing and offer them access to some of the great tools that Mr. Marks suggests. Consider Big Brothers and Sisters of America or the scores of other organizations working to help kids overcome poverty.
  • Fight to keep your local library system open more, give it more resources, and help kids to use them for success.

Speak out!

What other problems do you see with the solutions that Mr. Marks offers? Which of his solutions do you find salient or salvageable?

What do you think it takes for a poor person or someone who suffers from institutional inequality to make it if the system is unable to help them?

-----

For those who are curious, here is what I wrote to the author:

“Sir, as a white kid who grew up on welfare in a single-parent home and went on to graduate from Stanford, you might think that I would support you. Instead, I am so incredibly disappointed in your ignorant “recipe” for success. I got into a magnet school that my mom found out about by sheer accident. I went to the library and read a lot because it was the only place with adequate heat and electricity. The problem? I got evicted more times than I can count. Our utilities got shut off so often. I did not, contrary to your “teacher friends’” assessment, have a computer at home. Had I known about any of these tools (likelihood is that I would not have and that my mother would have been even less likely to as a waitress working 15 hours a day 6 days a week), I still wouldn’t have been able to use them. What library system could accommodate all the poor kids (of any race) to help them to realize this goal? Where would I find the time to use these resources when I started to work at age 15? Where would I get my stamina to study “coding” when we didn’t have enough food to eat dinner that day? It is articles like these that perpetuate the systemic ignorance of the role class and race play on success and prevent us from real solutions. You clearly do not understand what it is like to be poor, and your blindness is a danger because this article will only reach those who are well enough to-do to have an impact on policies that directly affect your mythical “poor black kid.” And those policy makers will make terrible choices that entrench systemic racism and class division even further in our country. Shame on you.”

Here is his response:

“Thanks for your comment. I still stick to what I wrote, and believe that the opportunity is there for everyone if they study hard and get good grades, use technology to help them get good grades, apply to the best schools they can, get help from their guidance counselor, and make sure to learn a good skill.”

You be the judge. Don’t accept inequality of opportunity. Don’t blame the victims. When one person succeeds, we all benefit in concrete ways. Our country’s future depends on everyone being proactive, not washing their hands of blame.

Wednesday, November 9, 2011

Reviving a Passion for Reading

Last Friday, I went to DC’s Politics and Prose bookstore for an author talk by Steven Naifeh and Gregory White Smith about their book Van Gogh: The Life, which I highly recommend. Apparently, Van Gogh’s family was big on reading. According to Naifeh and Smith

Every evening at the parsonage ended the same way: with a book. Far from being a solitary, solipsistic exercise, reading aloud bound the family together […]. Anna and Dorus read to each other and to their children; the older children read to the younger; and, later in life, the children read to their parents. Reading aloud was used to console the sick and distract the worried, as well as to educate or entertain.

While I would love to delve into the big problems of the education system, this passage reminds me of how becoming passionate about books was one of the biggest advantages I had in overcoming my circumstances. Let’s face it: we may want teachers to save our kids and prepare them for the future, but it is unrealistic to expect such miracles from even the best of teachers when they get at most 6 or 7 hours with a kid. So, I firmly believe that finding ways to engage kids outside of the classroom in a constructive way is essential to their development. One of the most important ways to do that is to go beyond just getting them to read, but rather getting them to love reading.


Growing up in Chicago, one of the best places to go in the heat of summer or icy winter was the library—and Chicago has a large network of libraries, some with great selections. We also had a phenomenal program called Book It! Pizza Hut would give you a personal pan pizza if you read 6 books in a given month. Finally, and perhaps most importantly, my mom would often read to or with me and would save up money to buy me new books.


Mom didn’t limit what I read much either. When it came time to buy that book for being good, it was often a book out of the Goosebumps series (no disrespect, R.L. Stein). My teacher contacted my mother to “let her know the kinds of things I was reading” (ironically for that Book It! program). My 3rd grade teacher was slightly taken aback when my mom calmly said, if Ryan wants to read a book—even if it is Stephen King’s Needful Things—then I’m not going to stop him.” While adolescence may have made my mom question her choice, in the end I think she was dead on. Not only did she empower me to make decisions for myself, but she also gave me ownership over reading and allowed me to enjoy it by choice not force.


When I taught in rural Panama, I faced a very different culture: reading was viewed as drudgery necessary for school at best or utterly useless in many cases. When I had spare time between planning lessons, I would often lay in the hammock under the mango tree with a book (and one of my host siblings and a bunch of chickens running around). My host mom would marvel at the amount of reading I did. She loved to ask the neighbors coming through the house, “can you guess how many pages Ryan read today?” They’d guess a “ridiculously high number” like 15 and then she’d drop the bomb, “No, 80.” I may have been responsible for a small number of aneurysms that year.


When adults and kids share the idea that reading is something that is inaccessible, irrelevant, or downright boring, it deprives the whole community and it makes it incredibly hard for teachers to be effective. Teachers often have to waste class time trying to force kids to read items that should have been read at home, often at a slower pace because the kid does not have the passion for reading or the focus that previous reading experience brings. That reduces the amount of interactive time among students and teachers, and denies kids the benefit of having a structured activity outside of the classroom to continue their learning. So much learning attrition occurs during the summer for kids that lack such structure, so it is particularly critical that they have this passion to bridge the time between lessons (especially for breaks over 24-48 hours) in a meaningful (and ideally enjoyable!) way. (Read more about summer attrition in learning and how it particularly affects low-income kids on the School Fest Blog.)


There are many benefits to reading, especially when you are poor:

  1. Reading requires and develops an intense sense of focus, as you need to recall plot, character development, themes, dialogue, and bring them together to get the most out of a story. Unlike Facebook, TV, and computers, reading demands and cultivates your ability to give your undivided attention. This skill of focus is what ultimately allowed me to become so good at studying foreign languages, completing complicated tasks, and realizing long-term goals.
  2. When done with others, it opens spaces for conversation and discussion. It is a great way for a parent to engage with their kids on complex issues, events, characters’ decisions and morality that may not otherwise present themselves. This social aspect (which is an important part of the quote I shared from the Van Gogh book) in turn makes reading more interactive and enjoyable and reinforces a kid’s love of reading.
  3. Reading a book gives you an opening to make a new friend when you see others reading the same book or a book you’ve already ready (just don’t be a spoiler).
  4. It reinforces your knowledge of grammar and builds your vocabulary. This in turn makes you better able to express yourself, communicate, and write. Importantly, it gives you alternative ways to communicate. Surviving poverty can require a lot of ingenuity, but all those talents are often unrecognized because others don’t take you seriously when you sound “uneducated.” Be yourself, but also know how to show the world what you've got to offer.
  5. Reading often requires that you bring something to the table to get the full story, usually a vivid imagination and a willingness to engage using your memories and experiences. In a country when start-ups and small businesses account for about 80% of job creation, we want people who are constantly engaging their imagination because exercising their creativity makes them more likely to come up with that product or service that will fill a great need and employ some people.
  6. The process of choosing reading prepares people for self-directed study and research, which can serve in schooling but also when you want to teach yourself how to fix a roof. In general, it creates an opportunity for kids to improve in their decision making and to take ownership over their learning outside of school.
  7. It gives you a form of escapism in new situations or a sense of belonging when a character or occurrence reminds you of something you've felt or lived.
  8. It is a quick way to experience many other ways of thinking and acting.
  9. Where there are libraries or free newspapers, it is a relatively low-cost or free form of entertainment.
  10. Reading has become intensely democratic: I could read Tolstoy on an annual income of $20,000 and a few years later Oprah Winfrey and millions of Americans of various social strata, backgrounds, and ages read the same book. I can also brag about reading Anna Kerenina before Oprah, so put that in your pipe and smoke it.
  11. Books are always better than the movie.

Now, if you are a volunteer, a teacher, or a parent, here are some tips from Missouri State on how to get your child to love reading that I think provide a good start (so too is the Van Gogh biography quote in this post). The gist is that you need to model behavior of loving books and reading whenever possible, being mindful of any potential vision impairments that may be preventing your kid from reading. I can’t help but think if only more kids got addicted to books instead of drugs or booze…okay, okay, I’m admittedly a dork. Nonetheless, it is never bad to give kids a leg up, a new hobby, and a chance to be Oprah’s equal without having to give an audience full of people new cars.


Act on it!

If you have kids, set aside a time where you read with or to them. Give them an opportunity to choose a book they are excited about, and read with them, ask them questions about the book, and see where it leads. You can strengthen the appeal of reading by creating a special, cozy place for reading or by making it a night that you do something special like bake cookies so that reading is embedding in a web of positive associations.

If you don't have kids, consider volunteering at a library, hospital, bookstore, or school.

Donate used books that have been sitting on your shelf (not just those romance novels, send some of those good ones, too) to public libraries and schools so that more people can use them!

Support your local bookstore and for your next night out, bring your friends or family and get them excited. There are amazing institutions like Politics and Prose around the country that need your support to compete with e-readers to stay afloat and offer cool programming that helps get people behind the text of a book or find that bridge between books and real life.

If you are in a position of authority with kids and notice they don't like or are uncomfortable reading, try to get their vision checked or look for conditions that may impede reading. Often times, it is an undiagnosed physical problem that makes a kid unable to enjoy reading. (read more about these problems at the Children's Vision Information Network.)

Insist that libraries are not cut from your local schools at their PTO/PTA/PTSA or with local government officials. Work with the community to find funding or alternatives when government or school budgets become tight. (Read this amazing article from Washington DC's City Paper about a woman who shaped libraries in an admittedly problematic DC Public School System).

Start a book club and let your kids know about it! Let them join or do a family book club too.

Start a book swap or find one and become active.

If you hear a child being belittled for reading or doing something bookish, subtly show admiration or praise to reaffirm that what they are doing is right (confronting the bully may not be the best strategy because it could lead to more teasing). Sometimes kids just need a role model to give them that extra push when other kids are mean and potentially could curtail a love of books and learning.


In the meantime, read something: you never know who is watching and might catch the bug.


Discuss it!

What are some ways you've gotten your kids to read?

What strategies help you to read?

How have you gotten involved in creating a culture of reading in your home or community?

Do you know a kid with a vision problem that affected reading? Share a story of the struggle and how you worked to overcome it!